Skip to main content

No, You Don’t Have to Turn Off Your Emotions at Work

Most of us are emotionally invested in our jobs, and for good reason. Professional success impacts our well-being, happiness, and sense of purpose. High stakes like these obviously cause a wide array of emotions, but we learn early on that showing too much of this at work is somewhat taboo. Acting on your emotions may make you appear combative, impatient, unreliable, or even weak.

This kind of thinking leads to questions: If showing emotion at work is bad, then how far should you swing in the opposite direction? Should you try to regulate your emotions to the point of never showing them? Do they have a place in your leadership style at all?

Don’t Shut Out Your Emotions
Red Hat CEO Jim Whitehurst, ranked #10 on Glassdoor’s list of America’s best CEOs, disagrees with the popular, sometimes unspoken rule to mask your emotions at work. He believes an emotional response is a “reflection of a person’s passion.” In fact, Whitehurst claims it might actually be a red flag if an employee is unable to express what they’re feeling.

In his opinion, choosing to hide your emotion weakens your influence. It diminishes your credibility with co-workers, higher-ups, and clients. Sometimes you become so focused on holding it together – masking your natural response – that you forget that ways in which expressing emotion can help you build trust, strengthen relationships across the board, inspire focus, and learn from failure.

In an article from Harvard Business Review, leadership and strategy consultant Doug Sundheim expands upon Whitehurst’s beliefs. He says, “Much of what comes out of people’s mouths in business these days is sugar-coated, couched, and polished. The messages are manufactured, trying to strike just the right tone. Genuine emotion stands in stark contrast. It’s a real person sharing a real feeling. When we hear it, we’re riveted — for one because it’s rare, but also because it’s real. Sometimes it’s uncomfortable and a little messy. But that’s what makes it powerful.”

The power he’s referring to isn’t entirely a product of passion or even “positive” emotion. He admits that emotions can be “uncomfortable and a little messy.” His point is, as a leader, your ability to inspire loyalty often comes from expressing honest emotion.

Regulate Your Emotions
Of course, none of this changes the fact that leaning too heavily on your emotions, or showing them too readily, can undermine your authority. Despite his clear approval of showing emotion at work, Sundheim concedes that when you lose control, it can “cloud objective analysis, screw up negotiations, and lead to rash decisions.”

If you’re experiencing an emotionally charged moment, you’re less inclined to listen, which means your peers don’t receive your full attention. Your brain doesn’t process information as well as it could either. Overall, uncontrolled emotion leads to disengagement. Thankfully, your ability to regulate those feelings can be strengthened like a muscle. The more you practice, the better you become at determining when you should and shouldn’t show your emotions.

Communicate Authentically Instead of Emotionally
So, which is worse? Showing too much emotion or not enough? Sundheim says that in “nearly two decades of working with leaders, I’ve found that showing too much emotion is far less of a problem than the opposite — showing too little.”

Perhaps the answer is not to show all your cards, i.e. every emotion you experience at work, but to communicate authentically. After all, authentic leadership is honest, genuine, and rooted in emotion. Whitehurst says, “The goal is not to show more emotion, the goal is to become a more authentic, effective communicator. Emotions should help you better communicate so you can get work done and get results.”

In light of that, here are four ways to practice authentic leadership:

Call Meddlers
Learning to strike a balance between emotional regulation and authentic expression can make you a more formidable leader. At Meddlers, we help our clients identify their strengths and weaknesses, and implement the kinds of strategies that unlock true potential. Contact us today to learn more.